OdeToCode IC Logo

MVC 5 In Retrospect

Thursday, June 13, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

I've been in the guts of an ASP.NET MVC 5 application lately and have some more perspective on the improvements we take for granted in ASP.NET Core.

Oslo in Oil

  • Tag helpers are far easier to read and write compared to HTML helpers. There were days when I wanted to give up on Razor views, but tag helpers make the Razor engine second to only JSX in terms of smoothness. Of all the different techniques I've used to dynamically generate HTML, JSX and TSX are by far my favorites, and I think that’s because JSX took the approach of embedding the declarative language inside the imperative language (HTML inside of JavaScript). Embedding in the other direction, as Razor and others have done (language X inside of HTML), always seems to create scenarios with awkward syntax.

  • It is refreshing to work with a framework that embraces dependency injection, like ASP.NET Core. ASP.NET MVC danced around DI and provides a hook for a central dependency resolver, but you always have to wonder if something might not work because you’ve strayed outside the lines.

  • The artificial separation between ASP.NET MVC and the ASP.NET Web API was unfortunate and unpleasant, but follows Conway’s law.

  • The startup logic for an ASP.NET MVC application is difficult to follow. There is code in global.asax and three or four other files in the App_Start folder. I haven’t been a big fan of how ASP.NET Core applications organize startup logic (see opinion 7 and 10), but even the worst examples are far better than the MVC approach.

  • Applications built before attribute routing was popular have the worst API routes.

  • Front end builds were easy and fast when all you had to do was bundle and minify jQuery and a few other files.

  • The scaffolding tools in MVC 5 are far ahead of the scaffolding tools for ASP.NET Core. Not only are the older tools considerably faster, but they tend not to throw exceptions as often as the ASP.NET Core tooling. Hopefully, ASP.NET Core will catch up.

Latest Course on Azure and VS2019

Monday, June 10, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

My latest Pluralsight course, released last week, is Migrating Applications and Services to Azure with Visual Studio 2019. The course is similar to my getting started course for .NET developers on Azure, but leverages more tools in Visual Studio. Migrating Applications and Services to Azure with Visual Studio 2019


Evaluating ASP.NET Core Authorization Policies

Thursday, May 30, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

Let’s say you have the following authorization policy defined in the Configure method of your ASP.NET Core’s Startup class.

.AddAuthorization(options =>
    options.AddPolicy("IsLucky", builder =>
        var random = new Random();
        builder.RequireAssertion(_ => random.Next(1, 100) < 75);

This policy will grant access about ¾ of the time. It is easy to apply the policy to a controller or Razor page using the Authorize attribute.

[Authorize(Policy = "IsLucky")]
public class SecretsModel : PageModel
      // ...

But, what if you want to imperatively check the policy? For example, when building a navigation menu, you want to know if the user will be able to perform a given action or reach a specific resource before displaying links and command buttons in the UI. In this scenario, ask for an IAuthorizationService type object in any controller or Razor page. The auth service combines a claims principal and a policy name to let you know if the user authorization check succeeds.

For example, in the page model for a Razor page:

public class SecretsModel : PageModel
    public bool IsLucky { get; set; }
    private readonly IAuthorizationService authorization;

    public SecretsModel(IAuthorizationService authorization)
        this.authorization = authorization;

    public async Task OnGet()
        var result = await authorization.AuthorizeAsync(User, "IsLucky");
        IsLucky = result.Succeeded;

And then in the page itself:

    <div>You got lucky!</div>
    <div>No luck for you :(</div>

Of course, having an authorization policy that uses a a random number generator is weird, but I'm hoping to work it into a "random access" policy joke someday.

C# Fundamentals Updated Again

Wednesday, May 29, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

Speaking of Pluralsight, I released an update to my C# Fundamentals course in April and I'm just now catching up with the annoucement. The course is focused on the C# language, but I decided to use .NET Core and Visual Studio Code when recording the update. Now, you can follow along on Windows using Visual Studio, but you could also follow along on Linux or macOS using any text editor. If you are looking to learn C# and some object-oriented programming techniques, I designed this course for you!

C# Fundamentals

Travelogue - The Pluralsight IPO

Wednesday, May 22, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

I have a difficult time stating that I left London early to reach New York City in time for a pre-IPO party without laughing at the gaudiness of it all. However, that’s what I did just over one year ago.

My Pluralsight story begins at a Visual Studio Live! Conference in 2007 when I met Fritz Onion in a speaker’s prep room. Fritz knew me from writing and blogging, and, eventually, our first meeting led me doing a "test teach" for Pluralsight.

A "test teach" is a short tryout involving real students, but it was more than just a check on my speaking ability. I believe the "test teach" evaluated several soft attributes. Could I build a rapport with the students? Do I handle questions well? Can I socialize at lunchtime? Can I successfully arrange and coordinate travel on my own to reach the customer? It’s one thing to plan a trip to visit a tourist attraction where signs and strangers would help you along the way. Planning a trip to arrive at a nondescript office building in a generic business park of Jersey City at a very specific time requires more expertise [1].

The test teach went well, and now I'm on a plane into Newark. Over the last 10 years I've taught dozens and dozens of classes all around the world for Pluralsight. I've made over 50 video courses for Pluralsight.com. The company is ready to go public, and I've been invited to the opening bell ceremony!

The Arrival

I’ve never been on a car ride into the city. I’ve always arrived on a plane, or underground on a train. But on this trip, I arranged for a driver to take me from Newark Airport to the W hotel in Times Square. It was my first time in a car through the Holland tunnel, and with all the traffic into the city at 7 pm, I had plenty of time to study the tunnel. The night was dark, wet, and foggy. New York had put on its Gotham city look, and I was waiting for the Batmobile to zoom past using an invisible traffic lane.

Arriving in Gotham

The pre-IPO dinner party was at Estiatorio Milos, a Greek seafood restaurant on 55th street. Milo’s food was okay. The place had the feel of an upscale restaurant designed to extract as much coin as possible from patrons while giving those same patrons the ability to brag to everyone about eating fish flown in fresh from the Mediterranean. Form over function. The company and festive atmosphere were better than the food. I joined late but found a seat among other authors, including Joe Eames, Deborah Kurata, and John Sonmez. Although there was talk of an after-party involving an ultimate milkshake, being on UK time, I needed sleep before the big morning.

Milo's Food Offering


Times Square in New York is an astounding place. Bright lights, tall buildings, and a mass of humanity moving through the streets. The ads are so intense they lead to sensory overload. There are animated ads for movies, which want to take your money in exchange for laughs. A four-story jewelry ad wants you to trade money for diamonds. Underwear, outerwear, phones, hotels, and banks all project images in a quest for branding and customers.

Times Square from a Distance

There was a time when I would have dismissed the square as being too artificial. But, after reading A Splendid Exchange, I’m seeing Times Square as a primal center of trade, and a natural expression of what humans have been doing for centuries. It is the place where humans come to make exchanges.

The Peak of Civilization

When we leave the hotel the morning of the IPO, the exchange we are looking for is the NASDAQ exchange on 4 Times Square. The NASDAQ is hard to miss thanks to the 7-story curved LED display outside. In fact, this NASDAQ location is really more of a media center than an exchange. The place has television studios inside, and rooms with hundreds of cameras where companies doing an IPO can ring the opening bell and look like they are on the trading floor surrounded by “traders” working diligently in front of computer monitors. The physical NASDAQ trading market exists only in silicon and fiber optics.

I’m one of only six or so authors who’ve been invited to be present for the IPO. There is also 50 or more Pluralsight employees, board members, and investors. A few of the people I’ve known for years and grown fond of. But with Pluralsight’s rapid growth, the majority are strangers to me. Nevertheless, we are bonding together like molecules in a high-energy physics experiment. I’m barely through the security entrance when Gene Simmons walks out of a TV studiio. He saunters over to 4 of us gawkers and in a Gene voice says, "So ... what are you gentlemen here to sell today?"

Me and Gene Simmons

You’ve never felt like a true nerd until you tell Gene Simmons about your training videos covering software development. It is impossible to perform this task without sounding like the D&D dungeon master at the corner table of a comic book store.

It Happens Quickly

During an IPO, there are two significant moments. The first moment is the opening bell ceremony. Not every company will choose to participate in the ceremony, but I'm glad Pluralsight did. For this ceremony, everyone gathers on the stage in a circular room. In the room there are dozens of electronic displays hanging from the wall, and even more cameras. The cameras cover every possible vantage point on the stage. There’s a podium on the stage, and NASDAQ people walking around wearing headsets, carrying clipboards, and giving orders with all the authority of a television producer. In the moments leading up to the 9:30 am market opening, they are giving us pep talks and telling us the more we clap and yell, the better we'll look on TV. I'm a bit worried that if we manage to add more energy to the room, we will start a chemical reaction that lays waste to the entire building.

The NASDAQ Media Room

At 9:30 am, the person at the podium (Aaron, in this case), takes a cue, pushes a button, and the bell rings. Confetti begins to fall. There’s yelling, clapping, and arm raising. I think of my parents. I wish they were still alive to see this moment. I’m one parental memory away from losing it and crying all over the stage. I can’t ever remember euphoria and sadness being mixed like this.

After the opening, there is professional picture taking, both inside the building, and outside in Times Square. There's also champagne, and singing and laughing, and selfies. Lots of selfies.

Ring the Bell!

The next big moment on IPO day comes when the first share of stock is publicly traded. I don’t remember the precise moment when this happened, but I think it was about an hour or 90 minutes later. There’s a roar when the price of the first trade execution hits the screens. There’s hugging, handshakes, and back-slapping. More selfies, lots of selfies.

First Trade Executed!

And then ... dispersion.

We leave the studios and head back to the hotel. Most Pluralsight employees are flying out in the afternoon to be back in Utah the same day. I’m beginning to think that if my driver can come early, I’ll get through the tunnel before rush hour hits and catch an earlier flight home. Flights between D.C. and Newark go once an hour when the schedules are working. If I can't catch an earlier flight, maybe I'll take the train. Either way, it’s not even lunchtime and I’m exhausted.

In the end, I did catch an early flight. However, before I left, I had a quiet celebration with a meal worthy of a billion-dollar IPO. I had a $5 hot pastrami sandwich from a street vendor two blocks from Times Square.

Function over form.

[1] Years ago, a renowned training company approached me about teaching a Web API class at Microsoft. For my first class, I was given a location on the Microsoft campus and told a Microsoft employee would be there to let me in the classroom. I arrived 30 minutes early and began waiting for my Microsoft escort to arrive. With 15 minutes left before the class started, I started emailing and trying to reach people at the training company to let them know my escort wasn't arriving. The classroom was in a locked down section of the building, and I wasn't getting past the entrance without my escort.

Finally, as my escort arrived 2 minutes before the class began, I entered the room in a state of panic. As I was setting up, I noticed that one of the well known instructors from the training company was sitting in the front row of the class. He was directly in front of my podium, and I heard him say, into his phone, "looks like he finally made it." I didn’t have time to think much of the statement at the time, as I only wanted to get plugged in and take a couple of deep breaths before launching into an all-day technical workshop for 70 MS engineers.

Later, when I replayed the opening events in my mind, I was furious. Why didn’t someone let me know he’d be there? Why did no one respond to my calls? Why couldn’t he provide me with an escort? After that experience, I think I finished one or two more classes for this training company that we had already arranged, and then I let the relationship expire quietly.

I tell this story because Pluralsight has always treated me with respect, and that's one reason I've been loyal and stuck with them.

.NET Core Opinion 13 - Commit Your Scripts

Monday, April 22, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

In a previous post, I suggested you think of your ASP.NET Core application as a command line tool you can use to execute application specific tasks. In an even earlier post, I suggested you keep scripts related to development checked into source control. I think you can see now how these two posts work together to make everyday development tasks automated and easy.

The command line renaissance gives us a wide range of tools we can use to speed up .NET Core development. Here are some of the tools I've been using recently, in no particular order:

  1. Various dotnet global tools, including dotnet-cake, dotnet-t4, and dotnet-rimraf

  2. The Windows Subsystem for Linux, because it opens up an entire universe of standard tools, like Curl

  3. The Chocolatey package manager

  4. mssql-cli

mssql-cli autocomplete

  1. Azure CLI and aws-shell


Interview on CloudSkills.fm

Thursday, April 18, 2019 by K. Scott Allen

CloudSkills.fm podcast

There's a new episode of the CLoudSkills.fm podcast available, and the episode features yours truly!

In this episode I talk with Scott Allen about building and running applications in the Azure cloud. Scott is a legendary software developer, conference speaker, trainer, and Pluralsight author.

I hope you enjoy the show.